A Local Broker Who's Been on Both Sides of the Industry
We're Smart Stop Brokers — an independent insurance agency headquartered in New Richmond, WI, with a second office in St. Louis Park, MN, and licensed service across Wisconsin, Minnesota, and Iowa. When you work with us, you're not reaching a call center. You're reaching the person who quoted your policy.
From Captive Agent to Independent Broker — and Why It Matters
Before opening Smart Stop Brokers, Paul Schirmer spent years working as a captive agent — tied to a single carrier's products, rates, and underwriting rules. That experience made one thing clear: clients deserve more options than any one company can offer.
Going independent was a deliberate choice. As an independent broker, we work with dozens of carriers across personal, life, and commercial lines, which means we can shop the market on your behalf rather than fitting you into the only policy we're allowed to sell. That difference shows up in your rate, your coverage, and the conversation we're able to have with you.

The Agency's History, in Plain Terms
Smart Stop Brokers was founded in 2016. We came under current ownership in 2023, and since then the agency has grown its carrier relationships, expanded into commercial lines, and built a client base across the St. Croix Valley and Twin Cities metro.
Our owner brings more than 17 years of insurance industry experience to every policy conversation — not a team average, not an aggregated number. One broker, one point of contact, one person who knows your file.
- Founded: 2016
- Under current ownership: 2023
- Industry experience: 17+ years
- Offices: New Richmond, WI and St. Louis Park, MN
- Licensed in: Wisconsin, Minnesota, and Iowa
- Carrier access: Dozens of personal and commercial carriers
What "Independent" Actually Means for You
Captive agents can only offer what their employer sells. Independent brokers can go to market. That means when your renewal comes in higher than expected, we have somewhere to go — we can compare rates across multiple carriers and find the coverage that fits your situation, not just the one that's available.
We handle personal insurance for homeowners, renters, and recreational vehicle owners across western Wisconsin and the Twin Cities. We write commercial coverage for small business owners throughout the St. Croix Valley and beyond. And we support existing clients through claims, policy changes, and questions — personally, not through a call center queue.
Frequently Asked Questions About Smart Stop Brokers
How long has Smart Stop Brokers been in business?
The agency was founded in 2016 and has been under its current ownership since 2023. Our owner brings more than 17 years of total insurance industry experience, including time spent as a captive agent before going independent.
Who owns Smart Stop Brokers?
Smart Stop Brokers is owner-operated. The same licensed broker who quotes your policy is the person you'll reach when you call, text, or stop by either office.
Is Smart Stop Brokers a real local business or a lead-generation site?
We're a licensed independent insurance agency with a physical office in New Richmond, WI and a second office in St. Louis Park, MN. We serve clients in person, by phone, and by text — and we're listed and verified on Google with current reviews you can read before you ever contact us.
What's the difference between an independent broker and a captive agent?
A captive agent works for one insurance company and can only sell that company's products. An independent broker like Smart Stop Brokers works with dozens of carriers, which means we can compare rates and coverage options across the market to find the right fit for your situation.
What states is Smart Stop Brokers licensed in?
We're licensed to write insurance in Wisconsin, Minnesota, and Iowa. Our offices are located in New Richmond, WI and St. Louis Park, MN, and we serve clients throughout the region remotely as well.
Two Offices. Three States. One Point of Contact.
Our New Richmond office serves clients throughout western Wisconsin, including Hudson and Eau Claire. Our St. Louis Park office extends that reach into the greater Twin Cities metro. We're also licensed to write policies statewide in Iowa.
Whether you prefer to come in, call, or send a text, you'll reach the same person every time.


